$1.1 Million for a Penny? How to Identify the Rare Lincoln Wheat Cent in Your Change

by Zoha
Published On:
1943 Bronze Lincoln Wheat Cent

Have you ever wondered if that old penny in your change jar might actually be worth a fortune? $1.1 million for a single penny might sound like a fantasy, but it’s a real possibility if you stumble upon the elusive 1943 Bronze Lincoln Wheat Cent. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll walk you through how to identify this rare coin, why it’s so valuable, and what you should do if you find one hiding in your change or coin collection.

The Lincoln Wheat Cent has always been a favorite among collectors, but the 1943 bronze version holds a special place in numismatic history. It’s a combination of historical context, minting mishaps, and rarity that makes this penny not only fascinating but extremely valuable.

Overview

Here’s a quick snapshot of what makes the 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent so unique:

FeatureDetails
Coin Name1943 Bronze Lincoln Wheat Cent
Estimated ValueUp to $1.1 million or more
Minting ErrorMade from bronze instead of steel
AppearanceReddish-brown, not silver-gray
WeightApprox. 3.11 grams (vs. 2.7g for steel)
Magnetic TestNot attracted to a magnet
Notable Sales$1.7M (1943-D), $1M (1943-S)

History

In 1943, copper was crucial to the war effort during World War II. So, the U.S. Mint switched penny production from bronze to zinc-coated steel to conserve copper. But a few leftover bronze blanks accidentally got pressed, creating one of the most valuable error coins in history.

These bronze 1943 pennies were never meant to be made, and their accidental creation turned them into treasures. Only a handful were struck before the mistake was caught, and the few that survived became legendary.

Rarity

Fewer than 20 authentic 1943 bronze Lincoln Wheat Cents are known to exist. Verified examples have been found from:

  • Philadelphia (no mint mark)
  • Denver (D)
  • San Francisco (S)

The 1943-D is believed to be the rarest, with only one confirmed coin.

Identification

Think you might have one? Here’s how to check:

1. Look at the Date

It must say “1943.” Watch out for fake coins made by altering 1948 pennies. Use a magnifier to check for unusual font shapes or tool marks.

2. Examine the Color

Steel pennies from 1943 are silver-gray. Bronze pennies have a coppery, reddish-brown color. Compare yours to a regular 1943 steel penny.

3. Use a Magnet

Steel is magnetic. Bronze is not. If your coin sticks to a magnet, it’s steel. If it doesn’t, keep testing.

4. Weigh It

Use a digital scale that reads to the hundredth of a gram:

  • Steel: Around 2.7g
  • Bronze: Around 3.11g

That tiny weight difference could mean big money.

5. Check the Mint Mark

  • No mint mark = Philadelphia
  • “D” = Denver
  • “S” = San Francisco

All are rare, but the 1943-D is one-of-a-kind.

6. Look for Clues

Watch out for uneven rims, poor spacing, or off-center designs—these might indicate a fake or altered coin.

Auctions

Some verified 1943 bronze cents have fetched eye-popping prices:

  • 1943-D: Sold for $1.7 million
  • 1943-S: Sold for $1 million
  • 1943 (Philadelphia): $300,000 to $500,000 based on condition

These coins have become legends in the coin-collecting world.

Scams

Because of its value, this coin attracts fakes. Here’s how to avoid them:

  • Don’t trust appearance alone—copper-coated steel can look similar
  • Use both magnet and weight tests
  • Check the number “3” in 1943 for signs of tampering
  • Get expert verification

Authentication

Get your coin professionally graded to prove it’s real. Two trusted services:

Grading boosts authenticity and resale value.

Other Pennies

Even if you don’t find a 1943 bronze cent, other Lincoln Wheat Cents can be valuable:

CoinWhy It’s ValuableValue Range
1909-S VDBFirst year, low mintageUp to $1,000+
1955 Double DieObvious doubling on letters and date$1,000 – $15,000+
1922 No DMissing mint mark due to worn dieUp to $10,000

Finding a million-dollar penny is rare, but not impossible. Check your change carefully, learn the signs, and stay informed. Whether you’re a casual hobbyist or a serious numismatist, the thrill of the hunt is part of the fun—and you never know when your next penny could be worth a fortune.

FAQs

How much is a 1943 bronze penny worth?

It can be worth up to $1.7 million depending on mint and condition.

How can I test my 1943 penny?

Use a magnet and digital scale. Bronze is heavier and non-magnetic.

What color is the 1943 bronze cent?

It’s a copper or reddish-brown color, not silver like steel cents.

Where can I get it authenticated?

Send it to PCGS or NGC for professional grading and authentication.

Can 1943 steel pennies be valuable?

Yes, but not nearly as valuable as the bronze error versions.

Leave a Comment